WHY DO BLIND WINE TASTING?
We humans are highly impressionable creatures.
We pride ourselves for our reasoning, logical, and distancing ability to be impartial in most all matters.
Yet despite the talk, there is very little to back this sentiment up. And certainly don’t try to do so with your judgement during wine tastings!
By tasting wines blind - you essentially level the playing field amongst all wines, or at the least, amongst all wines from a specific region or of a specific varietal that you’ve chosen to taste test.
Impartiality is the upholding principle in wine tastings and wine ratings.
So if we know beforehand what wines we’re tasting, that impartiality will be irreparably damaged - perhaps completely lost.
Here’s an example that proves this point:
In 2001 a famous experiement took place about the psychological effect of the “confirmation bias” - and not only that, but the experiment focused in on the wine drinking experience itself.
Frederic Brochet, professor at the University of Bordeaux School of Enology, tested the ‘impartiality’ we all believe we possess, against the ‘confirmation bias’ principle in psychology.
The experiment went like this:
What’s the final (perhaps predictable) punch? The Grand Cru and the vin de table, the duo that generated such polarized reactions and descriptions from the tasters, were both in fact the very same wine - a red Bordeaux that Brochet judged fell squarely in quality between both labels presented.
Brochet concluded that:
“It was observed that the label...influenced, in a preponderate fashion, subjects’ representations...A tasting with or without labels does not produce the same representations. A real organoleptic appreciation of a wine should be carried out in the absence of all imaginary reference.”
As a casual wine drinker - one who doesn’t have a reputation and career as a wine critic, writer, or sommelier at stake - this point may be moot.
Visiting a winery for a wine tasting, it’s all but impossible to not let the wine labels, the winery atmosphere, and the staff behind the bar influence how you experience the wine.
But even so - blind tasting has its place for casual wine drinkers too.
Blind wine tastings help wine drinkers sharpen their perceptions and make them more astute and sensitive to the wine in their glass.
Learning to pick up on the flavor profiles of different types of wines can instantly make you more confident in sifting out the ‘good wines’ from the rest.
Plus, at the end of the day, blind wine tasting parties are just fun, and make great wine tasting party ideas...
There are two methods for blind wine tasting:
“Double blind” is blind wine tasting in its purest, most extreme form, where the wine taster is given absolutely no reference, information, or imagery concerning the wine.
The wine taster is truly left to her one devices to detect what type of varietal(s) have been used to produce the wine, what region the wine might be from, etc, etc.
The problem with the double blind wine tasting method is that is completely erases context - which in fact blurs one’s otherwise good judgement about the wine.
“Single blind” tasting means that some context on the wine is given, without it interfering with one’s perception of the wine’s quality.
This means that some context is provided - such as vintage, appellation and grape variety, as appropriate. What is not disclosed is the wine brand, wine maker, or of course, price point.
It could be argued that even an appellation reveals too much information - since some appellations have a longstanding history of excellent wine quality.
Even so - the single blind method is what most serious wine critics employ to keep their impartiality intact, including tasters at the Wine Spectator, the wine magazine that has generated over 250,000 reviews, vowed on impartiality and pride in one’s love of wine.
* * * * * * *